E.H. Taylor’s MSRP is one of the most searched topics in the bourbon world—and for good reason. While the official prices stay low, retail shelves tell a different story. This post breaks down what each bottle actually costs today, and whether it’s still worth chasing.
| Bourbon | MSRP | Retail Range | Bottled in Bond | Proof | Tasting Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Small Batch | $39.99 – $59.99 | $95 – $150+ | Yes | 100 | Caramel, vanilla, light oak; solid entry-level pour. |
| Single Barrel | $62.99 – $79.95 | $150 – $200+ | Yes | 100 | Barrel-dependent profile; spicy oak |
| Barrel Proof | $62.99 – $79.95 | $250 – $339 | No | ~125 | Brown sugar, pecan, vanilla bean |
E.H. Taylor Small Batch
MSRP now $59.99 (up from $39.99)
Usual Price in the Wild: $95 to $150
This is the most accessible of the bunch. It’s bottled in bond at 100 proof, and it drinks smooth. Sweet and approachable with notes of caramel, vanilla, and a citrus finish. Honestly, if you see this for under $120, it’s worth grabbing. It hits way above its MSRP and is a great intro to the E.H. Taylor lineup.
E.H. Taylor Single Barrel
MSRP: $79.95 (as of 2025)
Usual Price: $150 to $200
Also bottled in bond at 100 proof, this one leans a little oakier. There’s variation from barrel to barrel, which is part of the appeal but also a gamble. You might get a fantastic pour, or you might get something average. For that reason, it’s hard to justify the price tag unless you know the bottle’s story or trust the store pick. Small Batch still gives you more bang for the buck.
E.H. Taylor Barrel Proof
MSRP: $79.95 (as of 2025)
Usual Price: $250 to $350
This is the heavy hitter. It’s uncut and unfiltered, usually landing somewhere around 125 proof. Big flavors here—brown sugar, pecan, vanilla, and a rich, warm finish. Comes from the same mash bill as George T. Stagg, and drinks like a cousin. If you spot it anywhere near MSRP, don’t hesitate. Even at $250, this bottle delivers a knockout pour.
Why Is E.H. Taylor So Hard to Find?
Short answer: demand. Long answer: Buffalo Trace doesn’t rush production, and most of these expressions spend years in the barrel. By the time they’re ready, stores can’t keep them on shelves. Secondary pricing doesn’t help either. Every time someone overpays, it reinforces the markup. Buffalo Trace is expanding, but don’t expect to see a real difference on the shelf for another 7 to 10 years.
Is It Worth Paying Retail for E.H. Taylor?
That depends on what you’re buying and how much you’re paying. Here’s the honest take:
Small Batch is worth it under $120
Single Barrel is hit or miss, and best under $200
Barrel Proof is a strong buy anywhere under $300
Every bottle in the E.H. Taylor line tastes good. That’s not the issue. The real question is whether the experience matches the price. For some expressions, it does. For others, it depends what you’re after.
E.H. Taylor is easily one of our favorite pours, and a bottle that should always be stocked on your bourbon shelf. It’s an accessible and delicious drink, that gives you a somewhat-unvarnished taste on what Bottled in Bond liquor should taste like.
Why Such a Gap Between E.H. Taylor’s MSRP and Street Price?
Buffalo Trace’s allocation process is tight to manage quality. Demand has far outpaced supply across their collectible bourbons. Prices rocket as soon as bottles land at retail. Expansion is underway but aged inventory takes years. Experts expect this dynamic to last into the early 2030s .
For a more detailed breakdown, read our writeup on “The Reason Why Buffalo Trace is So Hard to Find.” We’re also big fans of this writeup from Buffalo Trace Daily on recent price hikes with this bourbon.
Knowing the real MSRP helps you shop smarter and avoid falling into hype traps. E.H. Taylor is great bourbon. Just don’t let the sticker shock cloud your judgment. Stick to your price limits and drink what makes you happy.
E.H. Taylor’s MSRP: Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the MSRP for E.H. Taylor Small Batch?
As of 2025, it’s around $59.99. It used to be $39.99, but like everything else, prices have crept up.
How much does Small Batch actually sell for?
Most stores list it between $95 and $150. If you see it under $120, that’s a solid buy.
What about the Single Barrel MSRP?
That one’s now $79.95. It used to be in the low $60s range, but Buffalo Trace bumped it recently.
Why does Single Barrel cost more than Small Batch?
Each barrel is different, so every bottle is unique. You’re paying for that variation and the rarity of a good barrel.
What’s the MSRP on E.H. Taylor Barrel Proof?
Also $79.95. Good luck finding it at that price, though. It’s one of the most heavily marked-up bottles out there.
Why is E.H. Taylor so expensive in stores?
It’s simple: too many people want it, and not enough of it exists. Buffalo Trace doesn’t overproduce, and these bottles take years to age. So prices shoot up the second they hit shelves.
Is E.H. Taylor worth the markup?
Depends.
- Small Batch: Fair buy under $120
- Single Barrel: Worth it if it’s a store pick or under $200
- Barrel Proof: Justified up to $250, maybe $300, depending on the batch
Any tips on finding it at MSRP?
You’ve got to hustle. Sign up for store raffles, get to know your local shop owners, and keep an eye on state-controlled drops. Some places still sell at MSRP if you’re lucky or loyal.
Leave a Reply